This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
Bread and Butter Pickles you don’t have to can!
When I originally published this recipe, an unbelievable 10 years ago, I was an avowed Bread and Butter Pickle hater.
Haters gonna hate, am I right?
But not anymore. I changed my tune, I switched horses in mid-stream, and I turned over a new leaf. I can admit when I have been wrong, and I was SO wrong about this.
What, you might ask is all of this drama about? It was Bread and Butter Pickles that I disliked. I would have said hated, my feelings were so strong, but that is all behind me now. I will love these until the day I die. And, I vow to make them as often as I can. I’m certain that I will consume an uncivilized number of them every time I do.
Why did I hate them so?
What engendered my previous attitude? I’m afraid it was a family thing. My Mom and Grandmother always made bread and butter pickles. And though both are often cited on my blog as being an inspirational force behind my love of creating delicious food, when it came to bread and butter pickles, well, I just could not bring myself to eat those pickles.
They were SO sweet, and a bit limp and one note, with little subtlety. I know I didn’t have a lot of company in my hatred of B&Bs. There are just too many of them for sale in the store, and too many recipes online for my view of them to be one held by anything approaching the majority. But then I was never a fan of any sweet pickles at all. Dill pickles are my first love, and one of my promises to myself as a kid, was that when I grew up, I could eat as many dill pickles as I liked. I’ve not broken that promise to myself either – one of the most often viewed recipes on this blog is the one for my Refrigerator Garlic Dills, a recipe I make numerous times each summer.
Then, last winter, we went to one of our favorite restaurants, Maxie’s Supper Club in Ithaca. Something made me decide to try the Bread and Butter Pickles that Maxie’s serves, though I had avoided them in the past.
I was like “hey-wait-a-minute!” – these don’t taste like the bread and butter pickles I’ve had before! These are…….um, good! I liked them so well, that I asked the waiter for more, which he brought right out. In fact, he brought me some to take home too. He also gave me the manager’s card, because I was already contemplating making some of these little darlings myself, and if I could not replicate them to my satisfaction, I was ready to play the food-blogger card, and ask for the recipe.
But, that turned out not to be necessary, because I found a number of references to them online, and realized quickly that not canning them was essential to having them come out crisp and fresh tasting. Still – the recipes online looked a little too sweet, and lacked one ingredient that I am pretty sure Maxie’s version has.
Garlic is key
Garlic. You gotta have garlic. It is the perfect contrast to the sweetness, and gives them a more deeply savory flavor to balance out the sugar. If you are thinking that garlic and sugar aren’t a good combination, just trust me, and make a batch of these – heck, make half a batch if you are really skeptical – you’ll be back for the other half!
Less Sugar is also key
I fiddled around with the proportions before settling on this combo, but go by what you think you will like – as I mentioned, most recipes have more sugar than this one does. I would suggest you give my version a try, even if you like the sweeter ones because I think you will find that less sugar gives the other flavors a chance to shine.
These are also very easy to make, and if you make them in the morning, they will already be a little pickle-y by dinner time. It is crucial to make time for the soaking in ice and salt part – that sets you up for success and success in this case, is a nice crunchy pickle. The one thing I did like about my Mom making them when I was a kid, was snitching the cucumber slices from the bowl – ice cold, salty cucumbers – yum!
Equipment I used for this recipe: Mandoline Slicer ~
Bread and Butter Pickles
- 2 pounds of small cucumbers
- 1 large white onion
- 1/3 cup pickling salt
- About 4 cups ice cubes
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 cup white vinegar
- ½ cup cider vinegar
- 3 – 4 tablespoons pickling spice
- 3 cloves garlic minced
- Slice the cucumbers into uniform medium slices. I use a mandolin slicer for this because it is faster and an easier way to get the slices even. [see above link to one I like]
- Slice the onion in thin slices, on the mandolin, or by hand.
- Put the cucumber and onion slices in a bowl that is roomy enough for easy mixing.
- Sprinkle the salt over the vegetables, and toss together, lightly. Arrange ice cubes over the mixture. It should sit for at about 3 hours, but a little longer won’t hurt anything.
- Combine all of the brine ingredients in a 5-quart wide pan – you are going to mix all of the pickles in here, so you want a nice big pan.
- Have pan over medium heat, and stirring occasionally, bring to a boil. Turn off the heat, cover pan, and leave to steep until it’s time to take the cucumbers out of the salt and ice mixture.
- After 3 hours, turn the heat back on under the brine, and bring to a simmer.
- Strain the cucumbers, and allow to sit in a strainer or colander for a few minutes. Rinsing is not necessary.
- Once the brine is at a boil, add the strained cucumbers to the pan, and stir, as the entire mixture comes back up to a light simmer. Immediately remove from the heat.
- Place the mixture back in the large bowl, cover and set in the refrigerator for at least a few hours.
- I usually leave it overnight and jar the pickles up the next morning. They are perfect after only about 24 hours.
- These will keep for months in the refrigerator, so long as the pickles are under the brine. Obviously, if they look or smell bad, then discard them, but they will likely keep a long time. Makes about 3-4 pints.